For all the people below claiming you can't pray for non-Muslims and that's the "true Islam whether we like it or not", Nouman Ali Khan argues that's an incorrect usage of those Ayat that misunderstands their meaning (and that you can pray for non-Muslims): https://youtu.be/lDC5rWpfqvY

Side note, I really hate it when Muslims think their understanding is somehow the objective truth while other people's beliefs are them "making up stuff" or "believing what they want to believe." Hypocrisy at its finest. Like many things, there is a difference of opinion here so why are us random people on the internet quoting an Ayah out of context somehow more knowledgeable than scholars of Islam. Subhanallah.