Idk what you want to do and tbh idc its your choice and im not telling you what to do. With that said... I play both builds so I’m talking from experiences with both all that versatility speed and athleticism only helps with defense really...

Midrange ratings don’t matter cause every build can hit a mid range shot EZ, and layups dont max until i think 92, ball control and passing haven’t maxed yet for me and im a 93 overall, as well as i dont dunk often any way because on both builds i play PG(dunk tendency is very low for all pgs). The 3s matter alot more for proam teams and such, so pure sharp is better and more consistent hitting 3s in my experience. Just because of badges and 99 off dribble 3 as well has 99 open/contested 3.

Nba 2k labs only shows what your attributes will be at 99 overall btw so unless u know youll be getting to 99 pure sharp is the wave.

Also my opinion is my opinion im only talking from the pov that i primarily play proam and teams always need a good pure sharp and shot creating sharp does not have the same 3pt range or consistency from 3pt area to be better than a pure sharp. Faster yea, higher ratings a lot of areas yea, but if you have iq the ratings will never beat your skill. A pure sharp is more effective for a deep range threat and mid range scoring in a proam setting.

In 3v3 modes like park none of what i said matters because its casual sliders everyone can make everything and everyone can dunk like its nba jam lol.