Sunscreen Recommendation! (this might be a little long)

Hi! First post here and have just recently started my venture into skincare. I've been reading so much here and over at r/skincareaddiction but I'm pretty happy so far with the routine I've started.

AM

Splash with water OR refresh with Garnier Micellar Water OR cleanse with CeraVe Foaming Facial Cleanser Paula's Choice 2% BHA Liquid Exfoliant CeraVe Moisturizing Lotion

PM

Garnier Micellar Water to remove makeup 2% BHA again (sometimes) (is twice a day too much?) CeraVe PM Facial Moisturizing Lotion Pacifica Coconut Prebiotic Water Rehab Cream

So clearly next I'd want to add a sunscreen. Recently I went on vacation to Los Angeles and put on sunscreen for the first time since probably last summer (I know) and I just grabbed like whatever from the drugstore, a Neutrogena dry touch spray for my face and Sun Bum spray for my body. Well I ended up breaking out in itchy red bumps wherever I applied sunscreen, so I'm guessing I'm allergic. I've been wanting to try a physical sunscreen but it needs to check a few boxes:

Good for acne-prone skin Sits nice under makeup Inexpensive Minimal white cast (if possible)

Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated. I'm willing to try anything. Thank you so much in advance!