Why I believe Jay Wilds

What do you mean IF it were a lie.

I never said that and have no idea how you could have interpretted that. This is the second time that you've displayed a complete disconnect from the conversation we are having. Which forces me to assume to things.

  1. You are not very intelligent and thus miss the obvious of this conversation and I should pity you and just ignore you.
  2. You are intelligent and manipulate subvert information to win the argument at cost of having a constructive conversation because you feel somehow ignoring and denying your faults proves you are a better and perfect person.

Now I don't want to assume either of those scenario's. But your next response is going to be the deciding factor, and I will give you benefit of the doubt that neither of those conclusion apply.

What do you mean IF it were a lie.

What I said was...

To reiterate a very simple and hypothetical point. If Adnan is innocent, what does that lie mean?

and...

It's only a "big" implication if Adnan killed Hae.

and...

what does that worst case scenario of adnan willfully lying about asking for a ride mean?

As In Adnan is (intentionally, deliberately, purposefully,) willfully + (fabricating, falsifying, deceiving) lying about his request to Hae about wanting a ride from Hae that day. But had no involvement with the murder of Hae. As in he is innocent of the charges.

It's a hypothetical argument for you to answer what the lie means in that scenario. Since you advocate that this lie is ginormous of implication and comparable to grand canyon of divide I was talking in my initial response.

So. TLDR version

That's the biggest lie, with the biggest implications of them all.

To reiterate a very simple and hypothetical point. If Adnan is innocent, what does that lie mean?

Your words "Biggest lie" and "Biggest implications of them all". Well, what if Adnan did NOT kill Hae, what does that lie mean then?

/r/serialpodcast Thread