The main concern for me with Kane is that he always seems that he wants to do everything. Almost like a greediness factor within him. He's on penalties and freekicks, but also the main focal point to anything Spurs do and all of that combined boosts his stats considerably.

Kane doesn't actually get too many assists and whilst he does drop deep to spray balls around and help out in the midfield, it's tough to say whether he'd fit in at another club or suit a different style. That's another worry i'd have and maybe define whether he's a great PL player or one of the best.

I agree with a few of your points but being brilliant at pens doesn't make you the best ever, and defensively he's not actually that brilliant. He doesn't track down too much or make last man tackles, which is to be expected as a striker.