3. CMV: It would be better for everyone to have a higher barrier to entry for gende...

CMV: It would be better for everyone to have a higher barrier to entry for gender/sex reassignment and a more narrow definition of what it means to be transgender

I don't think it's unreasonable for you to present ID when applying for women's social programs, for example.

I mean they could probably just look you up so at that point an ID may not even be necessary but sure I agree it's not an unreasonable requirement. What are we referring to with womens social programs specifically?

Also how would the sex on your ID work? Can you get it changed at some point in transition, you didn't really speak to the point about saying trans women are women but then saying a women is a adult female so I'm not really sure where you stand on this.

One of your highlighted statements was "A trans woman should be defined as “an adult male who has completed the sex reassignment process.”"

But at that point, given that "male: would mean "adult male human", are you not basically saying "women are men". Unless you mean "someone who used to be an adult male and has completed transition to female".

/r/changemyview Thread Parent
Previous
Next

Recently removed from /r/changemyview

CMV: Tiktok and social media is influencing the sexuality and gender identity of a lot of Gen Z'ers cmv: A youth who believes they are trans should wait until they are an adult to transition CMV: Prisons should function as quarantine instead of punishment CMV: Modern women only compare the richest 1% of men to the past to ALL of women when they invoke the "women used to be oppressed" card. The truth is men were just as oppressed. CMV: Conscription and draft is sometimes necessary. CMV: The "Body Positivity Movement" does more harm than good for those who are involved with the movement. CMV: infertility is the main reason that kids should not go through gender affirming care CMV: The trans movement is pushing gender stereotypes. CMV: IDK if it is already. But charging people for a live concert where you don't actually perform should be illegal CMV: it’s okay to say "women" instead of "birthing people with uteruses" Cmv: impregnating a woman 10 years older than me is a good idea CMV: "Don't chase people" is bad advice. If you love someone to get them. CMV: The benefits of intentional celibacy out way the benefits of sex. CMV: Sports competitions are inherently unfair and broken as a system CMV: there is no such thing as an acceptable target for body-shaming

More Random Comments

I'd rather be fat than have loose skin. A quiet apartment near NYC ? My city was recently hit by 15 tornadoes, and many neighborhoods have been destroyed. A friend of mine went to check on her property, and found 2 people looting her home. Silver2s are fake conspiracy theory Just because your another sexuality or gender besides a straight male or female, doesn’t mean I have to support you or have the same opinions that you do. Texas town bans abortion in all-male council vote GULF OF OMAN, June 13, 2019. This image provided by U.S. Central Command showing damage from an explosion, left, and likely limpet mine can be seen on the hull of the civilian vessel M/V Kokuka Courageous as USS Bainbridge (DDG 96), not pictured, approaches the damaged ship. [740 x 540] Daily General Chat - June 14, 2019 Weekly Therapy Talk Thread Unionize! Amazon sued over Alexa illegally recording children The Weekly [Fresh]ness - week of Sunday, May 26, 2019 My new Toro mower is garbage 'A Quiet Place 2' Will Explain How That Whole Monster Situation Happened RS5 owners. What kind of money do you make annually to be able to afford this beautiful car?! Did you buy it in full price or lease/finance? If the latter, what’s your monthly payment?