I created a tinder profile with the photos of an extremely attractive and cool looking male model whom I follow on instagram (this guy has about 3 million followers, a cute dog and more friends than I have known people all my life)
I got about 20% matches. To try out, I just said "Hey want to hook up?" or something like that to all of them. All unmatched me (the model)
When my likes came back up, I only swiped the hottest of the hottest girls: I got about 10% matches. Started talking normally (gaming, however you'd like to call it) and what do you guess happened? I got the same phone number/nudes rate as I would have just talking to girls on another online environment with my own pictures.
Do good looks provide a slight advantage at opening? Perhaps +50% to women's receptivity? (30 out of 100 girls are receptive instead of 15) YES, OBVIOUSLY, D'OH, WHADAYA THINK?
Do good looks carry you anywhere beyond that without game: No. Perhaps one or two odd unattractive girls will want to keep him around in order to brag to their social circles, but that's it. Might not even get laid. Being unattractive is a gut feeling. Her pussy wouldn't want you.
Who would win if one of us (with game) and a really hot male model (with game) walked up to the same girls at a bar environment?
the male model almost every time. because girls go there for validation, mostly sexual. they dont care about your personality or dating prospects with you, they are too drunk to hear you play the cube game, it's too loud to tell them your new routine or do some C&F.
That's the thing with bars and clubs and tinder... If you specifically GO TO ENVIRONMENTS WHERE GIRLS GO IN ORDER TO HUNT GUYS: guess what? You will mostly fail if you don't fit some arbitrary standards those girls have put in their minds by popular culture and the media. (I got a sixpack and ripped lean body. why? I fucking love pie, and I used to get more girls when I was fat. Why? Because.. influenced my the media :p )
What will happen if you go out in daytime, or at night, and game women who are not specifically out to hunt for guys? You will close most of the time, with natural game.