[Discussion] next year: Hyde or Mixon

Really, that’s the line for you? Your argument right now is that 3.6 = let’s see what happens, 3.4 = drop immediately without hesitation? 3.5 and 3.2 are both awful without factoring in context. Would you have dropped Bell because of that alone?

It’s funny that you think Bell was “borderline salvageable” though lol. Melvin Gordon is also “cut me now level” right? Todd Gurley last year? Borderline salvageable? All below 4.0 at one point, all capable of being top 5 if not 3 RBs in fantasy. Devonta Freeman was terrible his rookie year. Still waiting for Coleman to take his role? You’re just being contrarian.

A lot can change in one year. Nobody here is waiting for Mixon to take them to this year’s fantasy super bowl (at least I hope not). Watching the games, the talent is there. People are looking forward to the possibilities if the team around him gets better via the draft, coaching changes, free agency, etc. It’s possible the situation stays horrible and, despite his talent, you end up being correct and he never has significant fantasy value. In dynasty I tend to think it is alright to see how a situation shakes out before i decide what to do with a player.

You are free to drop him in your league though.

/r/DynastyFF Thread Parent