[Discussion] Thoughts in Best Girl's Initial?

Unidolized R Definitely one of the better Initial R cards. She looks rather cute with the smile, but the eyes that are facing up are quite weird to me. Still a cute card, though.

Idolized R There isn't many negative things to say about this card tbh. I like how luscious her hair looks under her hands like that, and the flower on top of her head is quite pretty. I guess the way her figure is drawn so tinily is off-putting, but that applies to all the other Initial R cards idolized.

Unidolized SR Meh, the paleness of her skin is something that throws me off so much about this card (and the Initial SR's in general). Maybe also her not-so-happy expression. The hat is also rather plain and her dress looks like she got it from her grandmother (or Eli's lmao).

Idolized SR Ah, much better than the unidolized. Pale skin is still odd, her cleavage as well. It looks like one breast is bigger than the other? The dress is really cute though, I like the gradient. Her expression is also cuter and more smiley, which is nice. The headpiece is meh, I feel like it could do just as good with the flower only.

Unidolized Event I actually like everything about this card except her stoned expression. The dress is really cute, nice tea set, nice garters. But that expression just ruins everything for me.

Idolized Event Her face is at a weird angle, and that creepy smile isn't helping it either. The outfit is super cute, though. I love black+white+red! The plaid, the striped garters, and the red shoes are all so adorable! If only that face was drawn a bit better >_<

Unidolized UR I love this card. so. much. Her outfit is perfect, I adore the flower print and the shorts! Also the lighting from the window is nice, it adds more atmosphere to the card and makes Maki look more delicate. I also really like her expression, it looks dreamy to me (is she staring at someone? hehe) Her hair also looks gorgeous in this card, all the separate strands make it look thicker. I also really like how her figure here looks bigger. She takes up more space in the card, to me it makes her look older and more mature like a third-year (it's easier to see in the (transparent version)[http://i.schoolido.lu/cards/transparent/126Transparent.png]). Definitely one of my fave UR's of Maki!

Idolized UR aaaaAAAAAAAAAA. My idol queen<333 She looks so gorgeous in this card!! The outfit and its patterns look really great together, and the flower in her hair with the braid is super cute. The flashing lights also add some more glamour to the card!

/r/SchoolIdolFestival Thread