basically what I was trying to say is that you have this preconceived notion that what happens at this place is something to be concerned about.

The simple fact that a group of prominent men (US presidents and politicians, amongst others) are a part of a secret society is disheartening to me.

Fraternities are 'secret societies'. anything can be a secret society. I just don't see why there are crazy assumptions made about this one in particular when in all likelihood it's a bunch of friends (yea, they're probably friends because of how often they interact in business) like running around and fishing and shit

Does his credibility change the tangible evidence that they perform mock human sacrifices at Bohemian Grove? Does Alex Jones being a fear mongering loudmouth change the way that David Gergen responded in the interview when asked about the cremation of care "ritual"?

Yea, you're right, it is an obvious logical fallacy. I suppose I could have made my point by another technique.What I was trying to highlight is the fact that Jones has a history of taking things (like the LHC) and blowing the reasoning behind them way out of proportion. Logical fallacy? Sure. Reasonable human conclusion to draw? Hell yea.

Does Alex Jones being a fear mongering loudmouth change the way that David Gergen responded in the interview when asked about the cremation of care "ritual"?

But when I'm asked about my fraternity handshake, I'm not supposed to tell other people. Like I really think this stuff is this simple. It's a boys club where they have a weird ceremony to kick it off, take off their costumes, say "who wants some whiskey" and they start playing a shitty game of Texas Hold 'Em.