A dozen Scottish football rebrands. (OC) Livingston was well received, let's try some more.

From a professional point of view.

You're designing them for the made up brand that you've now given the PL. Almost the same soulless kind of design for everything and christ man, quit with the drop shadow. Aberdeen - Passable, but you're hiding the mark behind all that texture. There's a reason the badge has a white background originally, it lets it stand out.

Airdrie - The type is the most uninspired MS word type that you could've chosen, the original isn't much better, admittedly, but now you've taken it away from something incorporated into their badge into something floating away at the top and the bottom and actively makes it look out of place and boring. I see what you're trying to do with still incorporating the rooster, but that shape will get lost on a kit, it's too blocky.

Celtic - You've actively made more difficult to read with that typeface. Try bring that down smaller than what you've designed to. You've also changed a very iconic mark in the clover to something completely uninspired and almost like something a celtic da' would have on his arm.

Dumbarton - Have the castle, the rock or the elephant, don't haphazardly add the Rock as a section of the elephant where it's hidden to the point I had to go "oh, it's not just bad pentooling, it's actually supposed to be a silhouette"

Hamilton - You've missed the boat on the badge, it's supposed to be "H A" I can tell, but it looks more like a M at worst or "N A" at best. Not sold on the skewed flowers

St Mirren - Purple is showing through the N - sort your layers out. You've also taken anything that makes the St Mirren badge unique (which isn't much, sorry lads) and turn it into something that would look akin to a yank high school team logo. Where's the research?

/r/ScottishFootball Thread Link - behance.net