There’s lots of decisions that I disagreed with but at the end of the day it’s subjective and I guess some people would disagree, so I wouldn’t say that all of them are riggory, more that I just didn’t agree with them. There’s also been times where I’ve agreed with the decision but most of the fandom haven’t. Some that come to mind from the first five Seasons are -
Shannel not winning the makeover
Pandora being in the top three on episode one over Jessica, Sonique or Jujubee. Also Morgan winning the challenge over Tyra, Jessica, Sonique or Jujubee felt odd to me
They should’ve gone a high placement to Jessica for the Snatch Game, it was iconic and on a Snatch Game where so many Queens did badly she was easily the third best
Pandora should’ve been in the bottom two instead of Jessica for the episode that Jessica went home. I might be biased because I’m a Jessica stan but Tatianna was the obvious bottom two and Pandora didn’t do anything particularly memorable, at least Jessica was funny and entertaining and at that point she had the second best track record after Tyra
Pandora’s makeover in all honesty wasn’t that bad. It should’ve been Jujubee and Tatianna in the bottom two but they seemed to prefer the way that Tatianna presented the looks over the fact that Pandora’s looks were more coherent
Carmen being safe for the Snatch Game when she should’ve been in the bottom two, Yara should’ve been the one who was safe and either Delta or Mariah should’ve placed low
Carmen should’ve been in the bottom two over Alexis for that cake challenge
Raja should’ve been in the bottom two over Yara for the patriots challenge
Alexis should’ve placed high or won the singing challenge
Alexis should’ve won the makeover challenge
Raja should’ve won the Money Ball challenge
Either Phi or Milan should’ve been in the top three instead of the Princess for the apocalyptic runway
Madame LaQueer was worse than Dida in the Glamazons v Champions challenge but I’m not mad about this one as it gave us Dida’s iconic lipsync
I don’t mind Willam winning the boat challenge but I think that Phi Phi and Latrice had better concepts?
Sharon’s win for the political challenge was deserved but it’s confusing how she was praised for her serious approach but Widow did a similar thing and was criticised and put in the bottom two?
Chad should’ve won the makeover challenge over Phi Phi. Really bad outfits but great makeup, the only Queen to get that part on point lmao
Honey or Coco should’ve won the lipsync challenge over Lineysha
Alaska should’ve probably been in the bottom two over Detox for the makeover challenge