My first thought when I understood where Chloe was steering the conversation was wow, please don't make me do this. I will do it if you ask but please don't make me. So I went the third option of I don't know, we spoke for a while longer, and then when Chloe asked again I gave her what I could to help her find peace.

The worst part of that section was that upon entering the photo I had this sense of dread that trying to save William would create a completely different reality and turn out for the worse. If the game had given me the option, I would have left the keys alone and let William die. Death, simply, is a fact of life. With no way to know how the effects of that would ripple out, and knowing that I couldn't be there to fix things that went awry during the five year gap, it seemed so irresponsible. So when I saw Chloe for the first time I was devastated. I had known the potential consequences and Chloe suffered for my choice.

Spoilers Ep 5: (spoiler)[I guess that's why I made the choice to save Chloe at the end of EP 5. I couldn't make a decision that would hurt her like I did before.]