Here's the best I've found. (I'm not saying these are good. I'm just saying they're the best I've yet found.):
1st place (almost logical): Logically show that technologically advanced aliens probably exist, then make the baseless assumption that this implies a god created us.
2nd place (painful, but interesting): Point at quantum weirdness as evidence we may live in a simulation, then make the baseless assumption someone must operate the simulation.
3rd place (I've heard worse): Actually know enough about science to defend fine tuning, then make the baseless assumption the fine tuning was probably done by the conscious figure-head of their preferred religion.
4th place: (ug, not again) Observe that belief in religion has value, then make the baseless assumption this somehow implies religion must be true.