In a fight to death, which weapon would you choose: knife or baseball bat?

IMO knife is the clear winner.

It's one rhino charge with your arms protecting your head to get in close. I don't believe that the baseball bat can do enough damage with one swing to stop you getting in close, especially if you protect your head.

If you're close and you still have a grip on your knife, the fight is over. Baseball bat can do jack shit once you're grappling / on the floor.

Win conditions for the baseball bat are: KO the other guy in the one chance you get to swing while he charges you.

Win conditions for the knife are: don't get taken out in 1 hit on your charge and reach him with knife still in-hand.

The win conditions for the knife are 9999x easier to meet than the conditions for the baseball bat.

/r/videos Thread Link -