Forcing players to roll HP when leveling up makes the game less fun

In my recent games the past few years it seems like there's always someone who gets totally slaughtered on their stat rolls and 1-2 others who basically roll near-perfect beings.

Everyone is always affable about it at first but as the game progresses you can really feel the quiet animosity building when the low-roller ends up totally whiffing everything they were supposed to be good at while something like a Fighter becomes our religious encyclopedia by the mere nature of rolls.

I'm generally a fan of point buy these days as a result but everyone I play with greatly prefers rolling in hopes that this time around they'll be the Mighty Adonis protecting our meek Cleric who could probably get curbstomped by a farmer.

/r/dndnext Thread Parent