This season I’d say Squishy has had the higher ceiling but Garrett has had the higher floor. I suppose it just depends on which of the two you rate higher. Squishy has better pop off potential (and has a different level of LAN mentality than nearly anyone) but Garrett is known as being the most consistent player of all time for good reason. He’s also shown himself to be one of the most adaptable pros over the seasons (although lately Squishy has as well in his new role on NRG)

My mark is usually “if I’m building a new team of players and I can only pick one of them to be the backbone of my roster, which do I pick?” and by that measure I think you have to go Garrett. Mechanically I think Squishy almost unquestionably has the advantage but Garrett is just … Garrett lol