Coolest moment -- probably my first exalt drop. My friend who introduced me to poe hyped up the rarity of exalts (I think he felt they were about as rare as mirrors actually are) so when I finally found one, I felt like something really special had happened. Obviously I now know they're not so rare, but at the time 1 exalt was enough to fund my entire build and I was ecstatic.

First choice would be the 2 socket shroud of the lightless because I actually dropped one of those last league and sold it without knowing its true value. Other items I'm particularly interested in are the plague hold/ventor's/greed's embrace as I'm currently running an MF character on standard, attempting to farm doctor cards.