Individual opinions are subconsciously influenced by collective opinions. Due to, for instance, among other reasons, fear of nonconformity. Yeah, bandwagon effects are real. Therefore, I wonder if such effects are what you sense or notice, on some level. The names you listed all have critical masses of contemporary, living-and-breathing fans who praise their quality—more than enough to strongly push their bandwagons at present (and by any chance did you mean GREEN BOOK, a more timely example, in the news lately, than GREEN ROOM?).
If my guess is right, then regarding to your last request, I suppose some Letterboxd lists I made half a year ago can cover it: "'The 21st Century’s 100 greatest films' according to BBC Culture" and "'THE NEW CANON: The 23 best films of the 2000s' according to The Washington Post".