Hey, I am a amateur photographer, can I just get a honest opinion on this! Criticism is welcome

If you insist: It's a snapshot. It's pretty boring and composition is non-existent. Nothing works together, there isn't much of a story, the houses on the left are cut off for no good reason, the rocks are in the center for no good reason and everything is uneven and unbalanced.

It looks like there are people in the water. That could have been a so much better motif. Lie flat down, focus on the people, maybe you need a telephoto, try to get the mix between gray and fiery sky and water to work as a backdrop that's giving more contrast and attention to the people. Maybe there is also a better position on that beach to work with the rocks and houses + their interior lights to add more depth. You could have done a much better photo in this situation. Cute sunsets/sunrises are not enough of a motif. They are nice backgrounds for something interesting.

/r/pics Thread Link - i.redd.it