How could Galadriel survive to ..... ? (spoiler from episode 6)

my explanation (leaving aside the fact i have no idea what the rest of the characters will do)

We do, considering Elendil, Isildur and Miriel have to survive this event.

about the other characters surviving would be that its tolkien fantasy, ppl dont die often, whether it makes sense or not

Oh, so you clearly don't know what you are talking about.

i was talking about galadriel because thats what you were bitching about

Yes, and your explination does not hold water. No, elves could not survive this, not even in anything Tolkien wrote.

but, leaving aside what you wrote, it's very evident from Tolkiens works that elves can survive a lot when its convenient,

Oh, so you actually have not read any of Tolkien's works.

and die normally when that is convenient,

Not true.

so yes, Galadriel surviving is perfectly fine,

No it isn't.

just like her dying would be perfectly fine

It would not be fine if they want the rest of the story to happen.

And I will do the thing with Frodo and Sam if you admit you don't know what you are talking about. Deal?

/r/LOTR_on_Prime Thread Parent