Why do a lot of rural Americans (particularly in the deep south) say 'You want I should...?' instead of 'Should I...?'/'Do you want me to...?' Where did that come from?

It sounds like a direct translation of a sentence from German to English.

Prior to WWI, there were 9 million German speakers in the US. At the time, the country had a total population of 92 million, so quite significant.

Here's an example of a German sentence translated word for word to English.

  • Ich komme aus England, deshalb kann ich zurzeit nicht so gut deutsch verstehen.

  • I come out of England, therefore can I to this time not so good German understand.

Outside of Texas, I don't think there was a significant population of German speakers in the southern region. In northern regions, this may have just become part of the dialect for a small group of people. It sounds oddly specific.

/r/AskAnAmerican Thread