Lol you don't talk for me. Maybe I have a different opinion because I've had different life experiences. Like a guy who would shut off his emotions and not let me in... But no.. Of course I am an evil witch too. Because you know me so well. Honestly this is similar to something that did happen to me, my ex would show bursts of emotion and then close off and brush me off not wanting to talk about it. I felt like he didn't trust me enough to show his emotions... Which I encouraged. Just like with my current BF of 3 years. I actually asked him to let me in so I can support him when he's going through things. But yeah your right, shes bad, he's good and there's no grey areas in his situation. Good job