I use MakeMKV to rip my DVDs, then use HandBrake to compress the MKVs and import them to Plex. Is it better to import the original MKV files or HB compressed MKVs to Plex in quality terms?

Once you have compressed the RIP with a lossey method like MP4 you can NEVER get that quality back without going back to the original and re-ripping it again.

On your setup today you may never see the difference, how about in 5 years on a giant 4K screen? It may show then. 1080P will always be 1080P, it will never look better on a higher rez device, the compression that it uses may be able to be seen.

I have not experienced this on my video files yet, although audio CDs I ripped back in the 90's at 64k sounds pretty crappy today compared to 128 or 256 or a raw file on a quality stereo or playing device with quality headphones.

So, you have to decide, space or future proof quality? Me? I pick space and rip all my stuff to H264 and sometimes H265. I may regret it in years to come but for now it's what I do. Looks fine to me and sounds OK too. I've never been a audio / vido - phile anyway and my vision and hearing sucks anyway.

/r/PleX Thread