Manga wiki construction thread 12/28/14

I finally moved back to read a fair amount of manga after a couple weeks of light reading because of work.

Completed

I completed a couple of oneshots newly translated for Valentines day that where posted on this sub. Overall I was disappointed with these oneshots.

Chou no Ito 5/10

Joifo the best thing I actually completed this week. 6/10


So I read three works by Takekiya Jin this week. the first was one of the newly translated one shots. All are yuri.

Valentine's Magic (scanlator link) 5/10

Game - I read this one and the next one at /u/inanimatebananamint (sorry man in advance) suggestion after he said that it was better than Valentine's Magic. It is better in writing and the 3 chapters gave it more time to flush out characters if only a tiny bit. I found it overall sweeter and more enjoyable but it was still objectively bad to meh. This was the best work of hers I read. 5.5/10

Koi no Kaori - Yea this one was bad. It is a series of oneshots and two chapter stories. There were sweet moments and some humor that made me laugh which saved it from a lower score. The stories were predictable and dialogue bland. So many cliches and one dimensional characters. 4/10

Now what was the main reason I really do not like this author (other than her bad writing and that like every MC had A cup angst problems.). The art. oh god the art. It was not as bad as Yaoi hands but it was bad. It is the worst art I have every seen in a manga I have read. The eyes were so big that they felt like they took up 50% or more of the characters faces. Sometimes it looked like she just sorta copied and pasted a face onto a head and it was misaligned. Sometimes characters had not foreheads or weird boobs. Everything was inconstant. I could go on but you get my point. The art was actually half decent in Game which is part of its higher score but was god awful in Koi no Kaori. I am just gonna leave you with this.

Ongoing/Reading

Berserk -

/r/shwag945 Thread