Somewhere in the middle to lower. I'm not ranking them accounting for anyone else's taste just my own.

I really disliked what I felt was Donna's anti-intellectual attitude sometimes.

I felt a little like that about rose. Also, wasn't she dating Mickey but falling in love with the doctor? Amy tried to pull some crap like that but redeemed herself.

I loved Clara and Martha Jones.

Bill didn't really appeal to me and the way they wrote her was heavy-handed.

Nardone leaves me with mixed emotions. I feel like he was mainly written as a joke with little taken seriously which i guess annoyed me a little.

The new series i hate the writing for in general.