Muslim here - Why do you guys believe Islam is false and that Muhammad is a false prophet?

. When we look at the Bible when it uses the term "son of God" for the prophets or "children of God" it ain't literal likewise when we find in the Bible also that Jesus was called by JEWS in a crowd as "son of David" similar to the way Mary was addressed by a crowd as "O sister of Aaron", it WAS NOT LITERAL.

You claim you're not and yet again you still keep going on about the same straw man argument. I was not arguing for "sister of Aaron" to be taken literally, I asked for a reasonable justification for its usage. I have even, for the sake of argument, said that "sister of Aaron" could simply be taken the way you suggest, BUT that doesn't mean you're acquitted from providing the necessary evidence to prove that. All you have provided was the possibility that your understanding could be correct, not that it actually is.

So, in conclusion, that means the objection you Christians make of Muhammad being somehow confused about two Miriams and ignorant of Christian teachings is not true. In fact, it seems truer to what the Jews at that time would say about their own because of it being a way defined in the Hebrew language and the various examples like the one aforementioned and below quoted shows...

Again to reiterate, you have not actually proven this. Despite what you say, you are unwilling to engage in a genuine discourse on this matter; therefore, there's no point in continuing this. Your problem is that you aren't here for a sincere and critical pursuit of truth. I already knew this coming in, as it was implied in my original reply. The basis of what you constitute as fact and true are very weak, and that's coming from someone who is not a huge debater or apologist. Continuing in this way is not doing anyone any favors.

I think it's important to just iterate that I came into this in good faith, for a productive discourse, not as an attack on you. But it is very clear that this is getting nowhere, so I'm not going to continue a pointless thread. Regardless, I hope that you find some value in this. Have a good day/afternoon/evening, peace to you.

/r/Christianity Thread Parent