Hahaha, so basically you're asking me to name a hypothetical QB that literally doesn't exist. I gave you the closest equivalent who retired in the late 90's, you're literally asking me to name a QB who doesn't exist.

If a QB played during 2007 - 2013 and had Brady's stats and accomplishments during that time (2X MVP, 2X SB appearances, Pro Bowl literally every single year, first team all-pro, unprecedented record-breaking 2007 season coupled with perfect regular season record, 78 - 19 regular season record, made it to the playoffs literally every single year not including 2008 which he missed completely due to injury, a season with 50TDs and over 4800 yds, just to name a few) he would absolutely 100% be making it into the Hall. If you think Steve McNair comes anywhere close to that you are 100% out of your mind.