amazement
astonishment
awe
bewilderment
consternation
curiosity
disappointment
jolt
miracle
revelation
shock
wonder
abruptness
attack
bombshell
disillusion
epiphany
eureka
fortune
godsend
incredulity
kick
marvel
miscalculation
phenomenon
portent
precipitance
precipitation
precipitousness
prodigy
rarity
start
stupefaction
suddenness
thunderbolt
whammy
wonderment
astoundment
curveball
eye-opener
unexpected
unforeseen
anoetic
imprevisible
serendipitous
surprised
unforeseen
blutterbunged
inattentive
startling
unanticipated
unwarned
ferly
inopinate
struck
unaware
gloppened
mirific
sudden
unexpected
amaze
astonish
chill
daunt
dismay
distress
frighten
give a turn
make jump
panic
scare
scare silly
scare stiff
scare to death
spook
startle
surprise
terrify
unnerve
ambuscade
assail
assault
box in
bushwhack
decoy
dry gulch
ensnare
entrap
hem in
hide
hook
jap
jump
lay for
lurk
net
set trap
surprise
surround
trap
wait
waylay
astonish
bewilder
blow away
bowl over
confound
confuse
daze
dumbfound
flabbergast
knock over with feather
overwhelm
shock
stagger
startle
stun
stupefy
surprise
take aback
bafflement
confusion
daze
discombobulation
disorientation
perplexity
surprise
There. 100+ Words like surprise ;D
http://steamcommunity.com/id/Babooton/
Thanks for the chance!