3. On Ignosticism and Agnosticism

On Ignosticism and Agnosticism

An ignostic on the other hand has enough knowledge on something that he can conclude they are inconherent, contradictory, and inconsistent

Wrong.

Ignostic does not have to claim that "God" hismelf is "inconherent, contradictory, and inconsistent." What does it even mean for "God to be inconsistent?" You are a really straw-manning Ignosticism here.

Instead, Ignostic claims that DEFINITIONS of God that were provided so far are "inconherent, contradictory, and inconsistent."

Since the DEFINITIONS of God that were provided so far are "inconherent, contradictory, and inconsistent." - the only conclusion is that there really is not really a definition at all.

Which leads straight to agnosticism.

/r/DebateAnAtheist Thread Parent
Previous
Next

Recently removed from /r/DebateAnAtheist

Aside from organised religion, what do most atheists think about the evidence for the survival of consciousness after death? What are your arguments against evolutionary theodicy? Don’t worry, religious people don’t even believe. If God doesn't exist, where did everything come from? Why is Judaism never discussed in atheism / political threads I believe consciousness is fundamental. My argument isn't neccessarily supernatural. It's philosophy of mind to be specific Weekly "Ask an Atheist" Thread On the burden of proof. Is Numbers 5:11-31 about abortion being condoned in a certain context? Science and religion aren’t answering the same question. Objective morality How can you so surely believe in yourself? Not sure what to believe Homosexuality and Alcoholism Weekly Casual Discussion Thread

More Random Comments

FD Signifier criticizing Aba & Preach in his Manosphere video Why are you single right now? Antisemitismus an Schulen: „Physische Gewalt mehrheitlich von muslimischen Schülern“ eli5: Why is it impossible to imagine new colors? Real Photo of The President’s Notes for Briefing "Oh no, I'm now only mostly silent instead of entirely silent! Unplayable!!!" AITA for telling men I have a boyfriend instead of a girlfriend to get them to leave me alone? Does anyone not believe in casual sex? Morbius Impact - General Discussion and Questions Thread Just stopped playing the game when her section came up because her design made me cringe so bad as a kid (Rachel from Ninja Gaiden reboot) What would be the worst message to receive from space? UFOs, a lot of them I finally had a creepy experience with a driver How often do you get verbally abused at your retail job? How to get in 3000 calories in the evening and still sleep well?