OSRS - Should there be a degradable god weapon for each god?

but then the prices just swap. the degradable will always be cheaper than the non-degradable used to charge it.

say you made whip non-degradable in a tent whip right now. what do you think would happen to the price of a whip? sure, it might stay about a mil for a week, but eventually people will be needing their tent charges, and kraken tent is a 1/300 drop from a task-only boss.

then you pk someones 100k whip and act surprised that it's so cheap.

the solution is to make them degrade to a tradable broken state rather than disappear, and you can create a fully charged item with either a broken variant and/or either part of the weapon. that'll leave all 3 items around the same price range.

/r/2007scape Thread Parent Link - i.redd.it