But how would that be Apartheid if they’re not citizens? Israeli Arabs have full voting rights and equal status because they are Israeli citizens and not Palestinians. Palestinians wouldn’t have voting rights and equal status to Israelis because they’re not Israeli citizens, they’re Palestinians. If I move to Switzerland and don’t have full voting rights and access to their healthcare system because I’m not a citizen, is this apartheid? The responsibility of the state is to it’s people and to no one else, voting in Italy is for Italians voting in Slovenia is for Slovenians and voting in Israel is for Israelis, not Palestinians. A nation and it’s people doesn’t have a responsibility to anyone it doesn’t want responsibility for, and if that means evacuating the West Bank then so be it, but you cannot force a nation to give citizenship and rights to people it doesn’t want.