Philip Rivers to replace Ben Roethlisberger in the Pro Bowl.

You're basing which one is the AFCW's best off of this one season? Lol. Even your own stats aren't conclusively saying Carr is better - Rivers had more TDs and yards. Your only advantages are in completion (barely) and INT% (I'll be charitable). Win-Loss is a laughable metric here considering that's a reflection on more than just the QB. So let's just stick to the QB.

I've been talking shit about Rivers long before Carr was in the league

And yet you intentionally ignored his career stats. Figures - Must be because your shit is just that. Well here we go! Career stats! I'll be using %s and averages considering raw stats like total yards & total TDs wouldn't even be a contest:

ATT/G AVG/Pass YDS/G COM% TD% INT% Rating
CARR 36.9 6.5 238.2 60.9% 4.7% 1.8% 87.9
RIVERS 32.9 7.7 254.6 64.4% 5.3% 2.6% 94.7

What was that about Carr being the "better" QB? Maybe this season, but I'd like to see you say that with a straight face considering Felipe still had more yardage and got more TDs - he produced when the house was on fire (side notes: fuck injuries and I hope Carr fully recovers). But one season means Best in Show? Now in careers, I'll still give Carr the edge in INT rate, but Felipe scores more TDs in fewer tries and still gets more yardage w/ better accuracy. Yeah, Rivers is the better QB.

Get back to fighting with Alex Smith for 2nd place.

/r/nfl Thread Parent Link - profootballtalk.nbcsports.com