Previously On, /r/Survivor: No-Judgement Questions

Hindsight is 2020. We cannot trust what people say after the show. They may thought they knew how they would vote, but it may have changed in the spur of the moment (see Chelsea in GI flipping her vote). If dom didn't make it to FTC, and we asked all of the cast members what the result would've been, it would look like dom would have won, but that didn't happen. I seriously do not trust after-the-show surveys.

I ALSO THINK HE WOULD HAVE WON. I only wanted to present reasons why it may not have happened. Spencer is one of my favorites, but I wanted to take a second to get out of the circlejerk and look at some possible opposing arguments. He would have easily beaten woo, and would have most likely beaten tony.

No, we do know

No, we do not. Spencer was not as adored as many would like to agree. And, I definitely believe that he would have been taken out earlier if the firemaking twist was introduced. And I do not believe he beats either tony or woo in firemaking, either. As much as I would have appreciated a Spencer win, it is not as easy as you would like to believe, bud.

/r/survivor Thread Parent