Sharing my experience before anything else here. A married guy (10 years next month), who has moved from one place to another (cities as well as 4 countries)
There are pros and cons to both large cities and smaller ones. But here are a few things to consider
But apart from all of these, from your post I sense a lot of anger and frustration that may not be limited to this issue in particular. So tier1 or tier 2, problem may be elsewhere.