What are you guys' thoughts on these jackets?

This leather jacket I tempted to get, especially because of the F&F event, since its slim and there is an xxs since I'm pretty short and skinny. Only real downside is that its brown since I'd prefer black and its potentially faux leather? One of the reviews I read, which I for some reason can't see anymore, said that it was fake but the product description does say 100% leather.

I also like this car coat and I've wanted one for awhile, but I did get a peacoat last year as a gift for Christmas--albeit that was a bit more bulky + had a hood so it was bit hard to wear.