Reddit, what moment you realize you were in love?

When my girlfriend let me put a small butt plug in her ass that ended up going to far and getting stuck. Her being so embarrassed to go to the ER, I had to put my finger in there and pull it out. That was the first time my girlfriend ever encouraged me to stick my finger up her ass but it looks like it will also be my last. It was then when I was knuckles deep into my girlfriends asshole with her kicking and screaming in tears that I realized, she's the one.

This story somehow got spread to her brother "which is cool with me thank god" And at Christmas, with all her family together in the living room, my girlfriend couldn't get her gift open so her mother said to me "Hey SirChoGath, give her a hand" and her brother yells "OR A FINGER!"

Her face turned redder than my report card and he couldn't stop laughing. I got a very unwelcome vib...

Please don't let this become my top post. Or else my girlfriend might see it and stick something up my ass

/r/AskReddit Thread Parent