I think their size chart is reasonably accurate - I'm waiting on a size exchange right now, so I can update you in a few days after getting it (we have the same length foot).

I read a lot of reviews saying they were true to size, or that people sized down by 1/2 from their nanos, so I bought a pair in size 10 US since that's the size I used most often in other lifting shoes. I ignored Reebok's size chart that says size 10 US is for an 11" foot (my feet are 10.5" or 10.6"). Well....that was a mistake, because they were definitely too big. It's rare that a shoe is too wide for me, but the size 10 US was both wide and long, so I decided to do an exchange for size 9 US.

I'm guessing a lot of the true to size reviews are from people who were comparing vs. other Reebok shoes, because if the 9 US shoes end up fitting well, they'd be exactly true to size based on their size chart (where 9 US is for 10.6"), but not true to size compared to my shoes from other companies