Trumpism Is ‘Identity Politics’ for White People: desire for equal opportunity and a robust welfare state is mediated by the addiction of a large chunk of the polity to racial hierarchy

The privilege framework shares a root with totalitarian thinking, and it ultimately perpetuates the power structure that it attempts to expose.

The collapse of power and identity is characteristic of totalitarian thinking—a mode of thought that categorically excludes certain classes of people from discourse by appeal to insurmountable limitations of their identities.

By assuming that the identity of a person can shed insight on the structure of power pervading her argument, the privilege framework—even in its milder iterations that avoid an explicitly ad hominem form—finds itself awkwardly aligned to this mode of thinking.

While its aim is to expose how a seemingly universalistic argument neglects to consider the experience of an oppressed or marginalized community, the privilege framework establishes its claim by invalidating or diminishing the privileged interlocutor’s participation in discourse by appeal to an essential feature of her identity.

Although its objective is inclusion in discourse, it formally mimics the exclusion that is central to totalitarian thinking.

https://harvardpolitics.com/united-states/privilege-leftist-critique-left/

/r/TrueReddit Thread Parent Link - theatlantic.com