Watching this subreddit as someone who doesn't believe Adnan is innocent.

I agree with AnudderCast.
After listening to the podcast the second time around, I am now more convinced that Adnan is indeed guilty. I am more grounded on this decision for several reasons and some that were also highlighted in the podcast. Additionally, let me preface this by saying that I am aware SK-whether done subconsciously or not-was biased in her reporting of this case. She was team "Adnan is innocent", that was in-explicitly clear to me as a listener. Anyway, regardless of her personal biases, I have swayed over from team Adnan is innocent to team Adnan is guilty for these reasons: 1) the Nisha call. I refuse to believe that it was a "buttdial" that lasted 2:21. Adnan was the one who made the call. Adnan was with Jay. Simple.
2) Regardless of the motive reason...I believe that when it comes down to it, ADNAN would have more of a reason to murder Hae than Jay would've. Ex-boyfriend vs. Acquaintance. Ex-boyfriend wins. 3) Regardless of few a inconsistencies, Jay has a detailed alibi. Adnan doesn't. Shady. Seriously, how do you not remember the day you get a call from the cops that your ex-girlfriend is missing? That's not your average "regular day". 4) Adnan's "unluckiness". Seriously, if he was innocent..how UNLUCKY of him to have lent his car AND his cellphone to a guy that SAME day his ex-girlfriend goes missing. Nonetheless to the guy to ends up pointing his finger at him for his ex-girlfriend's murder. I find this very hard to believe. 5) Asking Hae for a ride. Jay says Adnan's planned to kill Hae by getting into her car. 2 people said they heard Adnan ask Hae for a ride that day. I don't believe that this was a coincidence. Jay's account of Adnan's plan is too specific for him to have just make that up.

I don't believe that either of them are being 100% truthful, I think that there's something that happened that happened that afternoon that they're not telling us. However, there's just overwhelmingly more corroborative evidence working AGAINST Adnan and little to no evidence supporting him.

/r/serialpodcast Thread