What are your arguments against evolutionary theodicy?

Yeah, like everyone else is saying. If God is omnipotent, which is what the abrahamic god is supposed to be, then he could make the universe in a way with humans and without evil.

As for evil only being possible if good exists, this is a philosophical thought that I shared when I was Christian. Evolutions take on it is different. To my limited knowledge on evolutionary biology, evil is anything that is detrimental to survival. Raping and murdering, for example, is going to piss someone else and they'll probably try to kill you, back during caveman times.

Also, "evil" wouldn't be my word choice to describe it. It's not really evil, it's nature.

/r/DebateAnAtheist Thread