What do you think is causing the surge in violence in Baltimore? How do we reduce it?

That is the 'goal' of Citystat/Compstat, but that isn't what it does.

Check the resources I have already given you. Act Two: Compstat/Citystat- Podcast

or

Act Two: Compstat/Citystat - Transcript

Offices were told to write more tickets, do more stop-and-frisks, arrest more people for low level offenses that they might otherwise let go-- get their numbers up.

We don't want police officers under such pressure to deliver numbers that they make stops and arrests and write summons with no valid reason, just to get their goals. Again, reporter Graham Rayman.

Graham Rayman: In other words, as a police supervisor I can't tell you, you better give me 20 tickets a month or else I'm going to transfer you to the graveyard shift. There can't be a direct relationship between the two.

But what was happening in the precinct, and what the tapes show repeatedly, is that they were tying it to disciplinary action. They were threatening the cops. If you don't hit your numbers, you'll get transferred, you'll lose your assignment, we'll change your partner, you'll go on a foot post, you can be given a worse assignment.


The pressure on police commanders to get better numbers really goes back to 1994, when New York started tracking crimes with a system called CompStat.

Eli Silverman: In the beginning it was like an orange. You could squeeze juice from an orange in the beginning much more readily than you can as you extract juice from that orange. And now, it gets harder and harder to drive crime down, because you're compared to not how you were in '94, but how you were last year the same week. And when something's pushed to the excess that it is now, and numbers dominate the system, that's when you have negative consequences.

/r/PoliticalDiscussion Thread Parent