Bruh, I'm super into anime too. Like, I eat it, live it, breathe it, draw it, sell it, make money off it, etc. Even my latest collection is based on an anime, I just pretended it wasn't and "modeled" it after the live-action instead. Just like you, you don't really see anything anime-related in my room... except that odd Kirito's sword sitting there, and maybe a handful of Pokemon and KnB figurines.

But it really, really depends on the guy. A lot of guys who like anime whom I've met tend to be pretty misogynistic and quite intolerant of what girls who like anime like - that's usually what I find is a turn-off. But if a guy who likes anime is open-minded, accepting and tolerant of these differences, he's a pure keeper.

So yeah, at least to me, a guy who likes anime and Japanese culture is alright, attractive even - but an intolerant and judgemental guy isn't. Actually, the latter applies to all sorts of guys, not just anime-lovers. I can't speak for every girl, but the personality and values are where I draw a line.