Who is the one you should not have killed??

I haven’t even watched matpat’s video on the stingers? So idk what he said but don’t lump me in as automatically saying all this because of Matpat.

The reason I say Jake and Andrew are symbolic of Cassidy and The Crying Child is because Andrew was killed by a bad man and that bad man get’s revealed to be Afton himself. Andrew the murder victim wakes up inside a shared headspace with Jake, and the two learn to navigate the world as a giant metal creature known as the Stitchwraith, with Andrew venemously hating Afton and wanting revenge. Sound familiar at all?

Idk how obvious it could get without Scott being too obvious but this is very VERY remenscient of what is supposedly going on between The Crying Child and Cassidy. In my mind why the hell would Scott write a random story completely meant to not have meaning, and then make it into the special epilogues and make it sound so so similiar to Cassidy’s tale. He’d have to be an idiot wanting to throw people off.

Anyway you could be right, let’s just see. To me it makes no sense for Scott to introduce a new child this damn late. We know the current dead children are Jeremy, Suzy, Fritz, Gabriel, Cassidy and Charlie.

Jeremy, Suzy, Fritz and Gabriel can be crossed out the list because they are confirmed the haunt the main band animatronics, and Scott does not place special emphasis on them in the gravestone ending and save them minigame.

That leaves Charlie, The Crying Child and Cassidy.

Charlie is not a boy and not vengeful, cross that off.

We are left with Cassidy and The Crying Child. Maybe Scott intended Cassidy to be originally a boy, but either way we know Cassidy is most likely the vengeful spirit considering CC being vengeful doesn’t make sense since his dad didn’t murder him. If the vengeful spirit isn’t Cassidy, then Scott introduced Cassidy for absolutely no reason and made her all mysterious for no reason. It only makes sense to me.

Anyway good theory and let me know if you figure out who it could be if it is a boy.

/r/fivenightsatfreddys Thread Parent