Who would you rather have between Benintendi and Happ?

I mean yes if you include his brutal cold streaks, he has the track record to show he can sustainably be who has been over the full season. He is currently batting .260 with no power, but I more meant in like early May when he was hitting .320. He didn’t really have the career numbers to support that that was sustainable, or even attainable again. I don’t think IKF is bad. He’s a decent end of lineup at bat and an average defender at short (I think? Really small sample there), which is an okay player. Gallo and Hicks should be replaced before him. He just doesn’t have Berti’s track record of above average or even really average offense.

/r/NYYankees Thread Parent