I mean let's look through Peyton's playoff loses, and you tell me which ones aren't his fault.

1999 - Loss against Tennessee 16-19. 19/42, 227 yards, 0 TDs / 0 INTs. Completed less than 50% of his passes, and barely had 5 Y/A. This loss is on Peyton.

2000 - Loss against Miami 17-42 OT. 17/32, 194 yards 1TD/0INT. To give Peyton credit, his defense didn't help him much in the 2nd half, but Peyton also only mustered 3 points after halftime. Can't put the entire blame on Peyton but he didn't do the Colts any favors.

2002 - Loss against Jets 0-41. 14/31, 137 Yards, 0 TDs/2 Ints. Probably the worst game of his playoff career.

2003- Loss against New England 14-24. 23/47, 237 Yards, 1 TD, 4 INTs. Needs no explanation. Peyton got beat up so bad they changed the rules.

2004 - Loss against New England 3-20. 27/42, 238 Yards, 0 TDs/1 INT. Extremely poor game from Manning and was only able to put up 3 points.

2005 - Loss against Pittsburgh 18-21. 22/38, 290, 1 TD/0 INT. Not a terrible game from Manning. Had a pretty good 2nd half, but it was too little too late. Vanderjagt missed a 48 Yarder that wouldve won the Colts the game. Would not put this one on Manning.

2007 - Loss against San Diego. 33-48, 402 Yards, 3 TDs/2 Ints. Peyton played a