As much as I'd like to see this, this might never be possible.

The left today, is an evolved version of the catholic church.

It has the same set of values - commitment towards missionary charity to appeal to masses - e.g. free healthcare, free handouts, absolute intolerance towards anyone who questions them rationally, general erosion of civil liberties, finding perverse ways to control copulation (for e.g. how talking about sex itself, is now sexist, sjw women - pretty much like nuns - have higher homosexual tendencies because of the stigma attached to having sex with a cisgendered man).

I can go on forever about it - but the point I am trying to drive is that part of the Christian ethos has always been to look down upon the jew and the pagan hindu. Friendship with jews and hindus is just not acceptable to many in America, despite Jews and Hindus having proved themselves to be better allies, and better immigrants than any other ethnic group in the united states, on any objective parameter. Our people have contributed to building their economy, paid taxes, ensured their children (the next gen) are assimilated, and they themselves loved America as much as their homeland. Most left wing americans would still rather fight for the rights of muslims and other minorities, who simply haven't contributed as much as the jews and hindus.

I am Indian, do not live in the US but another Western Country, and love America. However, the chances of an alliance like this - however great - is extremely unlikely.

I do not see Israel and India fighting anytime soon, if ever, and I hope that both countries have strong ties with America. However, the only way this is possible is through an entirely different America.