This will be my last post in this subreddit if this standard continues.

There was ample evidence and sufficient rules. We had dotabuff evidence. Stated in the rules. Dotabuff evidence should be self-explanatory. Fancy, 1.6k, and myself have all had lengthy discussions about why the dotabuff evidence is valid.

How can you say you had no rule? That is mind-boggling.

I enjoyed most of my time being a member and staff of this guild. The only way I consider returning as a simple member to this guild is if Afghan was banned immediately and any of the admins would acknowledge any of the evidence that has piled up: the 1v1 stuff, the unranked and ranked, even he doesn't defend himself. All Afghan says is it isn't my fault im placed in those games and tries to repeatedly put into peoples minds that because hes an okay person he should be allowed to stay. I've heard from at least 4 people they didnt enjoy playing w/ afghan because they got stomped. Some of the staff saying "well i beat him once" doesn't mean jack shit.

I've had more than one staff member approach me and say I was right, look at the response to this on reddit. Everything is public because the admins couldn't see it in private and still don't see it in public.

This post is well-intentioned, and I understand the shit storm that has flown this way. You called me and I laughed because I wasn't going to say anything different than what is said in those logs. Enclave doesn't understand how to moderate and isn't fit.

I'm done posting here, my last advice to you is if you want to make things right. Banning Afghan immediately (because "dotabuff evidence") is in the rules, and acknowleding the arguments that have been put fourth by myself and many others. That's how you repair this. Not saying you are going to lift and reconsider all previous bans and change the rules. The rules are fine and are fit to ban anybody who's dotabuff suggests they are higher than 3.2k. He was banned rightfully, and re-introduced wrongly on top of everything else. If I deemed torn was wrongly banned, and I know there were others who agreed with me. I couldn't just reintroduce him because he was "wrongly" banned. He was banned point and period. Nobody just brought him back in the snap of a finger. He's owned up to shit. Afghan is just here saying "dont blame me because i get placed in these games".

That's it.