3. My (probably unpopular opinion) about season 4: It was one of the best seasons

My (probably unpopular opinion) about season 4: It was one of the best seasons

I agree in some areas and disagree with others
The BCR
This subplot doesn't make sense.Why fight off a nation that is protecting you from the Nazis? If it wasn't for them Blacks would be exterminated or put into hard labor in North America. Another problem is making the group one race.Since the BCR is one race it makes them a easy target for Japs. Its weird to me that the BCR never mentions Africa.that only would be a good motivation to join the America Resistance so they could not only free people from the rest of America but Europe and Africa were black are slaves.

The Smiths
One of the best moments comes from this family but has a few flaws. One the train Helen is angry that John is going to cause a second Holocaust. Ok but why u feeling bad about this now? U been in the American Reich for 18 years and most likely hear or see people getting exterminated and said nothing Heck U made John join the Nazis claiming that its right and now is angry that he continue with that path?

What i would have changed
Why cant we have a ending where the Bad guys win? Its always America won and freedom return which is boring and predictable.It doesn't even make sense in this universe since the youth is brainwash and would fight to the death for their ideology. Japan and the Reich wouldn't collapse over night. It would take a few years if not decades for that to happen but since this is the last season, Thats why the real ending so so bad.

/r/maninthehighcastle Thread
Previous
Next

Recently removed from /r/maninthehighcastle

What happened to the famous people? As I finished season two, this is my biggest inner struggle. My issue with Season 1

More Random Comments

What dark secret are you hiding from everyone? 3 Months Clean From Fentanyl -AMA For All Mankind... another good concept ruined by wokeness Brainless player here, need recommendations for a PVE TCG deck that I can use to beat most NPCS Left my boyfriend, found someone better, but now regret it Tell me your best and worst advice as a new PL Is Norway forbidding what God requires?.. Requiring what God forbids? How are the laws contradicting his own? | Does God require a registered religion with money benefits? On the first date, what were some immediate red flags that made you not go on a second date? Want to move away from family permanently What dark secret are you hiding from everyone? [WP] A book that is written entirely through messages left on answering machine. Surprise this Subreddit exists, but I should know Reddit... What dark secret are you hiding from everyone? Staring death in the face , what are the bits of wisdom you wish you knew in 1996 that you know now Monthly Hask Anything (December 2022)