No one is denying Roger's talent but the man as a person is a colossal cunt in every way imaginable. Gilmour hardly ever mentions him and wants nothing to do with him. Imagine being in a band with that insanely massive ego all those years, taking insult after insult from him in the studio about your musical abilities.

David AND Roger both lost their ability to write good stuff after The Wall. AMLOR and Division Bell are still a hundred times better than The Final Cut though. If Roger had won that settlement in the 80s, do you seriously believe he would be so benevolent to the others? He'd be doing the exact same thing right now and much worse.